Private Watson Statue to be Moved

St. Catharines council voted 12-1

St. Catharines city council has voted to remove the statue of Private Watson from city hall in a move toward reconciliation with Indigenous people.

Indigenous groups say they are reminded of past wrongs when they see the statue.   The Private fought in the Northwest Resistance in 1885 against Metis Leader Louis Riel, who was a Member of Parliament, and founder of Manitoba, but hanged by the federal government in 1885 for leading two resistance movements.

Mayor Mat Siscoe pointed out there are other memorials in the city honouring veterans.  "The battle this statue stands in memorial of represents a government subjugating a race of people standing up for their rights.  The Northwest Resistance epitomizes the anger of Indigenous peoples over stolen lands and broken treaties."

The mayor added the statue is crumbling, and suggested it be moved to Private Watson's grave.

However, St. Catharines resident Dan McKnight said the statue is the first in Canada to a Canadian soldier.

"I understand the city did some consultation with stakeholders, including Indigenous groups, and the biggest area of consensus was 90% agreement that this memorial has historic significance," he said. 

Councillor Joe Kushner voted not to move the statue, saying it is a memorial to all soldiers.   There was also a suggestion to put a plaque at the statue explaining the history.  Many people have said they have no problem with the statue staying at city hall.